WooCommerce vs Magento: Which Is The Best eCommerce Platform?

Written By:Callum
Last Updated: March 06, 2024
Reading Time: 7 minutes

Picking the perfect ecommerce platform can feel like a giant puzzle, especially when you’re deciding between big names like WooCommerce and Magento. Both are awesome in their own ways, packed with cool features, and have lots of fans. It might seem tough to choose the best one without a little help. Lucky for you, that’s exactly what we’re here for!

We’re diving deep to give you the lowdown on WooCommerce versus Magento. We’re talking everything from what each platform can do, how fast and secure they are, what they’ll cost you, how beginner-friendly they are, and how they handle your products. We’re here to clear up the confusion, cut through the chatter, and help you figure out which one is the perfect fit for your online store.

It’s like having a map in the world of ecommerce platforms, where everyone seems to have their favorite and is not shy about telling you why. But don’t worry, we’re not picking sides. We’ve done our homework to give you the straight facts, so you can make the choice that’s right for you.

So, are you ready to dive in and find out which platform – WooCommerce or Magento – will help you turn your online store dream into reality? Let’s get started

What is WooCommerce?

WooCommerce, established as WooThemes in 2008 and later acquired by Automattic, the parent company of WordPress, is an e-commerce platform. Launched in 2011, it quickly gained traction due to its integration with WordPress and its free, user-friendly nature. Presently, it’s employed by over 3.9 million websites and has been downloaded more than 39 million times.

This open-source software facilitates the creation of online stores on WordPress websites. It offers a plethora of themes and plugins, enabling users to personalise their stores according to their preferences. Its versatility caters to diverse businesses, including retail, food, bookstores, and charity organisations.

Being free and user-friendly, WooCommerce requires no specialised technical skills, making it accessible to a wide audience.

WooCommerce Key Features

WooCommerce is free to set up and offers all the essential features an online store might need, including:-

  • Provides access to SEO and CMS functionality.
  • Modular framework that can be expanded with plug-ins.
  • Open-source, which provides high flexibility.
  • Easily integrated with CRM, inventory management, marketing and other leading softwares.
  • Has hundreds of region-specific payment gateway availability as plug-ins.
  • It has an integrated sales analytics option to expand the use of third-party plugins.
  • Average page load time of 776 ms.
  • Strong SEO features.
  • Advanced security features.
  • Nearly 10,000 free and paid WordPress themes.
  • Nearly 60,000 free and paid extensions.
  • A library of support resources.

WooCommerce is a free WordPress plugin. However, to use it, you’ll need a self-hosted WordPress site. This means you’ll have to pay for your domain name, web hosting provider, SSL certificate and WordPress theme.

WooCommerce Pros

  • WooCommerce is a free, open-source plugin for WordPress, making it cost-effective for starting an online store.
  • Highly customisable with thousands of themes and plugins for a personalised store appearance and functionality.
  • User-friendly interface suitable for beginners without advanced technical knowledge.
  • Benefits from WordPress’s strong SEO capabilities, enhancing store visibility in search engine results.
  • Supported by a large community for help, advice, and access to a wide range of extensions.
  • Offers flexible product management options, including physical, digital, and service offerings.
  • Enables global sales with support for multiple currencies and languages.
  • Provides detailed analytics for insights into sales, customer behaviour, and growth trends.

WooCommerce Cons

  • Additional costs can accumulate for hosting, premium themes, extensions, and plugins for extra features.
  • Potential performance issues with heavy plugin use or high traffic impacting user experience.
  • Managing a growing store can become complex, requiring more technical skills or external help.
  • It is a popular target for hackers, necessitating regular maintenance and security measures for protection.
  • Limited direct support, with reliance on community forums or hiring developers for customised issues.
  • It depends on WordPress, meaning any platform issues can directly affect your WooCommerce site.
  • Advanced features may present a steep learning curve for those without technical expertise.

Is WooCommerce Good For Beginners?

Yes, WooCommerce is great for beginners. It’s like starting with a free tool on a popular website (WordPress) that many people already know how to use. You can make your online shop look and work just how you want with many add-ons and design choices. Plus, a big group of users and experts are ready to help if you get stuck. But, as your shop gets bigger, you might find it tricky to handle everything without learning some techy stuff or asking for help.

WooCommerce Pricing

Cost Type Basic Site Mid-Range Site Advanced Site
Hosting $6.95/month $8.95/month $12.95/month
Domain Name $15/year $15/year $15/year
Theme Free WooCommerce theme Free WooCommerce theme $35-129 professional theme
Extensions Transaction fees Transaction fees Transaction fees + $100-400/year
Plugins Free $25-100/year $100-150/year
Security $10/year $150/year $150-450/year
Developer Fees Free Free $1,000-6,000
Approximate Annual Total $110 $300+ $1,500+

What is Magento?

Magento is a popular e-commerce platform for its user-friendly nature and customisation options. Users can personalise online stores using this open-source technology without sacrificing the shopping experience. Offering a range of helpful tools like marketing features and catalogue management, Magento suits businesses of all sizes, from small ventures to larger enterprises. Magento’s strength lies in its ability to adapt as businesses grow, providing both a free version and a feature-rich Commerce edition.

While it’s easy for beginners, handling many customers might make it more complex over time. Adobe acquired Magento in 2018, which is now operating within Adobe’s Commerce Cloud suite. This integration enhances eCommerce by merging Magento’s strengths into Adobe’s broader digital services.

Although Magento remains an independent platform, it’s now part of Adobe’s eCommerce and digital experience offerings, presenting users with an extensive array of tools under Adobe’s portfolio.

Magento Key Features

When setting up a Magento store, you’ll need a web hosting provider (a company that helps with website creation on the internet). Magento offers its users key features:

  • Marketing tools to improve conversion.
  • Mobile commerce.
  • Flexible PHP-based framework with an intuitive web page creator.
  • Enhanced search engines and mobile-friendly design.
  • Manage multiple stores and channels through one dashboard.
  • AI-powered personalisation for customer experiences.
  • A vast selection of both free and premium plugins, alongside API compatibility.
  • Native support for PayPal, Authorize.net, and Braintree, with additional payment gateways through extensions.
  • Features for content localisation, offering support for various languages and currencies.
  • Sophisticated marketing capabilities.
  • Multi-store management tools.
  • SEO features.
  • Catalogue management tools.
  • International customer support.

Magento Pros

  • Perfect for any size of eCommerce business, Magento grows with you, offering extensive customisation and expansion capabilities.
  • It comes packed with essential eCommerce features, with numerous third-party plugins for additional functionality.
  • A vast network of experts and users available to help with troubleshooting, advice, or as consultants for setting up your store.

Magento Cons

  • This may be overwhelming without coding skills, leading to longer and costlier development for smaller operations.
  • Only the premium Magento version includes hosting. Otherwise, you must arrange and pay for your server and domain.
  • Even with a free version, the extensive customisation and need for technical expertise can add up, making it a pricier option for getting started and upkeep.

Is Magento Good for Beginners?

Magento might not be the first choice for beginners, especially when compared to more straightforward platforms like WooCommerce. That said, with its comprehensive guides and resources, newcomers can still find their way. It’s best suited for those with big plans for their online store, ready to invest time learning how to use the platform effectively for rapid growth.

Magento Pricing

Magento’s open-source edition is free, making it an attractive option for those seeking to minimise upfront costs. The main expense for the open-source version comes from web hosting, which can range from $14.99 to $39.99 monthly. Other costs include:

  • Domain Registration: Expect to pay between $10 and $20 annually for your domain name.
  • SSL Certificate: Necessary for secure transactions, with prices between $50 and $600 per year.
  • Web Developer: Hiring a developer might be optional if you have the skills in-house. If not, costs vary based on the developer’s expertise.
  • Transaction Fees: Payment platforms and credit card processing typically charge between 2% and 4% per transaction.

Beyond these recurring expenses, Magento users should also budget for one-time costs like

  • Themes: A store theme can cost between $17 and $399. For a custom theme tailored to your specific needs, prices start at $5,000.
  • Extensions and Add-ons: While many are free, premium options in the Adobe Commerce store can go up to $2,000.
  • Choosing between Magento’s free, open-source edition and its premium versions (Pro or Managed Services) depends on your budget and the level of customisation and support you need.

WooCommerce vs Magento

Criteria WooCommerce Magento
Starting Price Free Free for open-source versions and several premium services.
Design and Themes Access to WordPress themes Variety of themes (paid and free)
Discounts & Promo Codes Create promo codes tied to product IDs Create rules for the price, cart discounts, multiple promo codes
SEO Tools WordPress SEO extensions available SEO included by default
Add-ons & Extensions 400+ extensions (free & paid) Nearly 4,000 extensions available
Security Depends on hosting; has SSL support Dedicated security patches, SSL available
Customer Support Lacks live chat; has documentation Community forum; premium plans offer support
Web Hosting Find your own host Self-hosted (Premium plans include hosting)
Scalability Supports unlimited products Varies on Commerce & Open Source versions
Ease of Use Beginner-friendly (Built on WordPress) Geared towards developers
Speed & Performance Varies based on the setup Varies based on setup
Extensibility Thousands of plugins, relatively affordable Thousands of extensions, but can be pricey
Marketing & SEO Built-in blogging; plugins available Extensions available; advanced tools in Enterprise
Pricing Free (premium Commerce version available) Free

WooCommerce, integrated with WordPress, suits beginners with its simplicity and availability. In contrast, Magento is robust and ideal for larger e-commerce operations but might require technical skills.

Both support major payment gateways, have extensive extensions and require proactive security measures. WooCommerce is more user-friendly, whereas Magento offers advanced features for scaling and marketing but might be more complex to set up.

WooCommerce vs Magento: 2023 Updates

Both Magento and WooCommerce have had significant updates in recent years that have changed how they work.

The major update for Magento was Adobe’s acquisition of the company and becoming its parent company in April 2021.

Here are some major 2023 updates for both WooCommerce and Magento/Adobe Commerce that may be worth your attention if you’re running a WooCommerce or Magento store.

WooCommerce 2024 Updates

  • WooCommerce 7.0 released
  • WooCommerce Filter UI updates
  • Product search is now a variation of the WordPress core search block
  • Cart & Checkout Blocks
  • Multichannel Marketing Experience (Beta)

Magento 2024 Updates

  • Adobe Commerce 2.4.5 Release Notes
  • Additional security enhancements
  • Platform enhancements
  • Composer dependency updates
  • Performance and scalability enhancements
  • Price indexer optimisation

WooCommerce vs Magento: Best eCommerce Platform for Your Online Store

Choosing between WooCommerce and Magento is quite the task because both platforms have a lot to offer. It really depends on what you’re looking for. If you’re just starting out or want to add a simple way to list your products and manage checkouts to your existing business, WooCommerce is your go-to. It’s user-friendly and gets the job done without a fuss.

But, if you dream of running a big online store with enormous products, Magento might be more up your alley. Its robust features are designed to handle complex e-commerce needs, offering scalability and flexibility unmatched by simpler platforms.

Now, if picking one feels a bit overwhelming, no worries! That’s what we’re here for. At Creato, we specialise in web design and e-commerce solutions. We know this stuff inside and out, and we’re here to help you figure out what works best for your business. Feel free to give us a call.

Let's work together

Do you need
creative Design?

Hey, I'm Callum. Here at Creato we re determined to produce creative Web Design. My only questions is, will it be yours?

About callum

Callum is the founder of Creato, a Sydney based design agency that specialises in creating holistic brands for Aussie businesses.

With a talent for crafting memorable and effective branding solutions, Callum has built Creato into a respected and successful agency. His work has been featured in various publications, including The Huffington Post, BuzzFeed, and Entrepreneur.

If you re interested in working with Callum and Creato to bring your brand to the next level, don t hesitate to get in touch!

Table of Contents